Clarifications, part 5

[bridgetmkennitt]

There are some nominated fandoms that, as far as AO3 and FFN numbers are concerned, are too small for Not Prime Time. If the nominators could please either comment below with additional evidence pointing to the medium size of the fandom or change their nominations to something else. You have until the night of April 14 (Eastern time) before I reject these fandoms from the tag set:

Chronicles of the Kencyrath - P. C. Hodgell
Deadwood
Rome
Stardust - All Media Types
Thursday Next - Jasper Fforde

Comments

[thegirlwiththemouseyhair]

I nominated Stardust, although I could definitely live and still most likely participate if it doesn't make it. However, I was about to nominate the 2007 Stardust movie based on the Neil Gaiman novella, then figured "Hey, I should do all media types to include the book too!", switched it to that, and totally forgot the exemption for movie fandoms which does not apply to other media. If you like, I can try to edit my nomination or if you like and have a way to nudge/set it to the movie that's also good. Anything, really!

[bridgetmkennitt]

The movie exception is for 100 fics on AO3 and Stardust 2007 only has 59 works so nudging it that way wouldn't work because it's unfortunately ineligible any way you slice it. 78 works for Stardust - All Media Types without putting in filters. 25 works for Stardust - Neil Gaiman without any filters. And on FFN, 48 fics in movie version and 30 fics in book version.

Unfortunately, unless you provide other evidence, Stardust is currently a fandom sized for Yuletide and Night on Fic Mountain.

[thegirlwiththemouseyhair]

Mea culpa; I guess I just didn't give the rules a sufficiently in depth read, but it's really no problem!