Nominations are now over

[bridgetmkennitt]

Nominations are now over. Corrections will run until Monday, April 18th and sign ups will open on the 19th.

Do you see duplicate relationships? A character in a relationship tag that doesn't belong in a fandom due to traveling bug? Relationships that were nominated/approved but aren't showing up? Discrepancies on fandoms/relationships that were approved? Something else concerning the tag set? Let me know within the comments below so I can fix it.

*Some fandoms will be in two different categories (TV and Books, as an example). That's a wrangling issue, so you can ignore that.

2017 nominations.

There are plenty of relationships left that need to be approved/rejected, but I should be able to finish that up by tomorrow.

Relationships:
Clark Kent/Kryptonian Tentacle Creature
-Is the Kryptonian Tentacle Creature this Shoggoth or something else? Let me know so I can approve it!

Fandoms:
Homicide: Life on the Street
Iron Fist (TV)
iZombie (TV)
Rectify (TV)
The Goblin Emperor - Katherine Addison

These fandoms are under the minimum amount on either AO3 or FFN. Is there another place that has more?

Comments

[the_rck]

Kurosaki Hisoka/Tsuzuki Asato is coming up both in Yami no Matsuei (where the pairing belongs) and in Weiss Kreuz (where it doesn't).

[bridgetmkennitt]

Fixed!

[jiokra]

Sherlock Holmes - Arthur Conan Doyle (5) ↑

Marcus Bell & Sherlock Holmes

Marcus Bell is not from ACD canon but the tv show Elementary. I didn't nominate this but I suspect they meant Elementary?

[bridgetmkennitt]

Fixed!

[(Anonymous)]

About Clark Kent/Kryptonian Tentacle Creature, I was misremembering it, I was thinking of this actually:
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/8/84221/2390849-brainy0001.jpg

That is Braniac's, err, creation.

[bridgetmkennitt]

Works for me! I'll go ahead and approve it.

[chomiji]

So my request for a friendship relationship between the two Zero boys, Natsuo and Youji, and Ritsuka in Loveless was deep sixed. It looked like this:

Sagan Natsuo & Sagan Youji & Aoyagi Ritsuka

Why? No one else put up the Sagans, in any combination, so now they're not in the tag set at all. I haz a sad.

[bridgetmkennitt]

That threesome relationship tag wasn't an AO3 canonical, so I rejected it.

[chomiji]

Clearly I need to review the significance of that concept. It never occurred to me that one could not request a novel relationship.

[(Anonymous)]

There's a duplicate in Rogue One: Mon Mothma/Orson Krennic and Orson Krennic/Mon Mothma.

In Turn, these two tags migrated from Hamilton: Alexander Hamilton/Angelica Schuyler and Alexander Hamilton/Elizabeth "Eliza" Schuyler

[bridgetmkennitt]

Fixed!

[(Anonymous)]

These two relationships are appearing in both The Closer and Major Crimes (TV):
Louie Provenza & Sharon Raydor
Rusty Beck & Sharon Raydor

It's not necessarily wrong, but I only nominated them in Major Crimes (TV), and it's unlikely someone else nominated them in The Closer -- while they did all appear on The Closer, Rusty was only in one episode, and almost all of Sharon and Provenza's interaction is on Major Crimes.

[bridgetmkennitt]

They might have traveled there on their own. Since the characters are on both shows, I'll leave them be.

[maidenjedi]

I feel like I'm missing something - why did "Mon Mothma & Jyn Erso" get the ax in "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story"?

No biggie, was just curious.

[(Anonymous)]

Not the mod, but it looks like Jyn Erso & Mon Mothma (Rogue One) is in the tagset. It may have been rejected as a duplicate?

[maidenjedi]

Thank you anon!

[bridgetmkennitt]

I just checked and the anon comment is correct, there's a Jyn Erso & Mon Mothma (Rogue One) in the tag set.

[maidenjedi]

Thank you, I was checking from mobile and couldn't get the tagset to load. Appreciate the follow-up!

Query: Batman Beyond/DCU

[graycardinal]

One of the nominators for Batman Beyond here:

I'm puzzled as to why "Barbara Gordon & Terry McGinnis" was rejected as a relationship; the only thing I can think of would be for the reverse form to have been a canonical tag, and I didn't think I saw either form go by when I was filling out the nomination form.

Also: I note that "Ra's al Ghul & Talia al Ghul", which I did nominate successfully in BB, has crossed into the DCU (Comics) cluster as well. (I suppose it's possible that someone else nominated it in that fandom, but I was eyeing that set of tags earlier and don't recall seeing it there at the time.)

Re: Query: Batman Beyond/DCU

[bridgetmkennitt]

Hrm. I could have sworn Barbara Gordon & Terry McGinnis was in the tag set for Batman Beyond, but it's not. I'll add that in later today.

It probably traveled to DCU (Comics), but that's okay. Both DCU and Marvel Comics got most of the traveling tags from other fandoms.