Updating Megafandoms

[bridgetmkennitt]

If you know of a fandom that should be considered a megafandom (over 20,000 fics) but isn't on the list, please reply in a comment below along with a link to an archive/comm/etc. This is so a) we have digital evidence of a fandom's "mega" status instead of relying solely on word of mouth, b) it gives fans who weren't aware of where to find those fics an opportunity to find a new treasure trove, c) your mods aren't aware of every part of fandom and they will miss things that may be obvious to someone else in their corner of the net, so help is appreciated.

The megafandom list can be found either on LJ or on DW

Comments

[halfeatenmoon]

My first reaction to the megafandoms list is that I think bandom should be included, but it's a difficult fandom to quantify in terms of fic. There's no central comm or archive. The fandom newsletter dotcoms_refresh keeps track of links via a pinboard account which has 18304 links tagged 'fiction' but doesn't include works in progress or fics under 500 words. In addition, while some bands under the 'bandom' umbrella have tons of fic - My Chemical Romance and Panic at the Disco each have over 10000 fics tagged by dotcoms_refresh - a lot of bandom bands are really under-represented, like Empires or Gym Class Heroes. So having looked at all that, I'm not entirely sure whether it should count as a megafandom or not. But I thought I'd bring it to your attention anyway, because it probably should be considered.

[bridgetmkennitt]

Thank you for bringing this to our attention. When we first started creating the megafandoms list, we wondered if bandom might fit the requirements, but we couldn't confirm or deny from first glance over because neither of us are part of the fandom and didn't know where to look.

I'll have to discuss this with Jenn and I'll get back to you with an answer.

[bridgetmkennitt]

Jenn and I talked it over and we decided to go bothways. The core bands of Fall Out Boy, My Chemical Romance, and Panic! at the Disco will be considered a megafandom. The second and third tier bands, like Gym Class Heroes will be eligible for Not Prime Time.

[halfeatenmoon]

I think this is an excellent decision! Thanks for taking the time to consider it.